Comments on: Those are my tomatoes! https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/ forget about today until tomorrow Fri, 27 Jun 2025 18:59:37 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4 By: Ragged Clown https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100440 Sun, 17 Dec 2023 16:18:02 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100440 In reply to Angela.

I took your excellent feedback into account when I wrote version two, Angela.

But no one will know because the new one is over here:

https://raggedclown.substack.com/p/those-are-my-tomatoes

]]>
By: Angela https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100439 Sun, 17 Dec 2023 15:21:12 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100439 Disclaimer!!!!! My comments relate to your original version of this article, they may no longer be relevant!

]]>
By: Ragged Clown https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100304 Sat, 11 Nov 2023 17:10:32 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100304 In reply to Ragged Clown.

The rich tomato farmers who keep their farms in their family for generations make it harder for the Miguels and the Theresas of the world to succeed. Everyone should have an equal opportunity to succeed, not just the children of rich tomato farmers.

]]>
By: Angela https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100303 Sat, 11 Nov 2023 15:09:02 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100303 In reply to Ragged Clown.

Hmmm! So Teresa who you say deserves her million plus pounds per year ( and I don’t disagree) on account of her talent for growing tomatoes is not going to be allowed to pass her tomato farm down to her offspring without risk of some Revolutionary coming along and confiscating it for the benefit of others who have no tomatoes. I’m just not entirely sure about this (will ponder it further), but perhaps you think it’s ok on the account of the morality factor!

]]>
By: Ragged Clown https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100300 Sat, 11 Nov 2023 11:25:43 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100300 In reply to Angela.

Thanks for the feedback, Angela! I love feedback!

I disagree with you on Rawl’s thoughts on who deserves what. I think it’s a moral issue. Morally, I think that Theresa and Miguel deserve their tomatoes. They worked hard for their tomatoes and the tomatoes belong to them legally (entitlement) and morally (deserve). I think that Rawls would disagree. We’d both agree that Sebastian just got lucky. He is entitled to them legally but morally, he did nothing to deserve them. There’s a moral difference between the three cases.

Come the revolution, I will have Sebastian’s tomato farm confiscated and the proceeds will be used to provide opportunities for people who have no tomatoes.

I disagree about the Difference Principle too. I’ll say more about that in episode two.

]]>
By: Angela https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100299 Sat, 11 Nov 2023 10:14:05 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100299 My other final thought … another great read Kevin 😊 (Final, final thought ie Afterthought! I know I have based my response on the ‘difference principle’ which you said u will address separately, but for me it is the linchpin of his theory and I can’t separate the two issues when appraising Rawls ) Blood hell! Another afterthought… I’ve just seen your comment from 3rd Nov! It seems my comments here were unnecessary 😫😂]]> Hi Kevin

I’ve always wondered if we interpret Rawls too literally. His point regarding desert…isn’t it really just a philosophical point! By which I mean, …upbringing, education and even propensity to work (by inheriting a ‘hard work gene’), all play their role in where people are situated in terms of equality/inequality with each other. His point regarding desert was purely to demonstrate that people ‘have more/or have less’ because of their original position of inequality. So he would probably say that Sebastian didn’t deserve (in a theoretical way) his tomato farm and the resulting profits, any more than anybody did.
That said, Rawls was not indicating that the tomato farm and its profits should be taken away from Sebastian. After all, we all need tomatoes!!! Sebastian could keep his farm and profits on account of the ‘difference principle’ which benefited the least well off on account of 1/ it provided work for many 2/ it produced health giving vitamin c enriched fruit (a fruit!!!) and 3/ the greater profits would result in greater taxation!
A point of debate is the precise application of the difference principle. My introduction to it was in A113 Revolutions, where Barber wrote ‘removing these inequalities would make the least well off even worse off’ which seems to imply to me that Sebastian can keep his tomato farm and profits (even tho he doesn’t technically deserve them any more than anybody else) since taking them away would make ‘the working class even more worse off’ in respect of 1/no jobs 2/no tomatoes and 3/ less tax to fill the potholes! (Rawls did actually say ‘the greater expectations allowed to entrepreneurs encourages them to do things which raise the prospects of labouring class’).

I’m sure the things you find contentious are purely philosophical/political points …and in reality he would agree with you, that talent, diligence etc should be rewarded. At least I hope he would! I certainly agree with you on that!

My final thought … ‘Give Rawls a break’ (to the tune of Lennon’s ‘Give peace a chance) 🥹

My other final thought … another great read Kevin 😊

(Final, final thought ie Afterthought! I know I have based my response on the ‘difference principle’ which you said u will address separately, but for me it is the linchpin of his theory and I can’t separate the two issues when appraising Rawls )

Blood hell! Another afterthought… I’ve just seen your comment from 3rd Nov! It seems my comments here were unnecessary 😫😂

]]>
By: Ragged Clown https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100239 Fri, 03 Nov 2023 13:45:31 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100239 In reply to Ragged Clown.

My copy of A Theory of Justice has just shipped. I’ll let you know in a few weeks!

FWIW I agree with you, David. I am a meritocrat and disagree quite strongly with Rawls’ egalitarianism.

]]>
By: David Hewitt https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100238 Fri, 03 Nov 2023 13:28:53 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100238 In reply to Ragged Clown.

Indeed, but for society to benefit from ever more and better tomatoes, the incentive needs to motivate the producer. How did Rawls (or communist Russian during the collective agriculture period) propose the worse off were to become wealthier, if not by this mechanism?

]]>
By: Ragged Clown https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100235 Fri, 03 Nov 2023 12:15:06 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100235 In reply to Matt.

Rawls was solving for Justice which he equated with fairness. It’s not fair to be rewarded or punished for something that happened by luck.

]]>
By: Ragged Clown https://www.raggedclown.com/2023/11/02/those-are-my-tomatoes/comment-page-1/#comment-100234 Fri, 03 Nov 2023 11:02:20 +0000 https://www.raggedclown.com/?p=6990#comment-100234 In reply to David Hewitt.

Rawls said that we can incentivize effort and profits are allowed, but only if they benefit the least well-off. Rawls was not a communist.

]]>